Knoxville's broader market recently sat at a median sale price around $325,000, with homes spending roughly 54 days on the market. If you're looking for the best neighborhoods in Knoxville, TN closer to downtown, the historic districts tend to pull your attention pretty quickly - and two names come up more than any others: Old North Knoxville and Fourth and Gill.
Both started as streetcar suburbs in the late 19th century and share boundaries along the Broadway corridor. They have distinct architectural styles, specific historic preservation guidelines, and different price points. These distinct features make the difference between landing in the right neighborhood and spending six months second-guessing yourself.
History and Layout of the Neighborhoods
Fourth and Gill came first, plotted in the 1880s for Knoxville's middle and professional classes. The area covers about 72 acres and landed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1985. The historic district includes 282 houses and buildings constructed between 1880 and 1930.
Old North Knoxville followed shortly after, established as the independent town of North Knoxville in January 1889 and annexed by Knoxville in 1897 - same as Fourth and Gill. It's considerably larger: 324 acres, over 500 historic buildings, and a spot on the National Register of Historic Places in 1992.
Both neighborhoods operate under H-1 overlay historic zoning, which means exterior renovations have to follow specific local guidelines. WATE news recently followed the restoration of a historic home on Oklahoma Avenue in Old North Knoxville - a good illustration of the preservation work that's been ongoing since the area's 1980s revitalization.
Real Estate Markets and Home Prices
The overall Knoxville market currently holds about 815 available homes at a median sale price of roughly $325,000. Historic district properties tend to price above that broader median. Sales volume in both Old North and Fourth and Gill is relatively low, which means the median price data can swing pretty dramatically from month to month.
Inventory is tight in both neighborhoods, and well-maintained properties don't sit. Knoxville homes overall sell for about 97.5% of list price. Recent projects like the conversion of the historic Brownlow School - which borders Fourth and Gill - into upscale condominiums continue to shape how values move in the area.
Current Home Prices
Recent estimates for Fourth and Gill put the median home sale price between $520,000 and $595,000. Single-family homes specifically can reach a median of $690,000, averaging around $359 per square foot. Some recent rolling averages have shown a median closer to $554,000.
Old North Knoxville comes in at a lower entry point. Median prices here generally run between $385,000 and $429,000. In periods with very few sales, reported medians have dipped closer to $265,000, though standard single-family homes typically sit closer to the $400,000 mark.
Architectural Styles
Fourth and Gill has some of the most recognized Victorian homes in the Southeast - Queen Anne and Victorian "painted ladies," alongside Gothic Revival, Mediterranean Revival, and Bungalow/Craftsman designs. Many were done by notable local architects including the Baumann Brothers and George F. Barber.
Old North Knoxville also has Barber designs, plus work by Charles I. Barber and David Getaz. The dominant styles lean toward Bungalow/Craftsman, Late Victorian, and Late-19th/20th Century Revival homes built between 1883 and 1940. Classic Queen Anne architecture exists in both districts if that's what you're after.
Commutes and Transit Access
Both neighborhoods sit along the Broadway corridor - U.S. Highway 441 - which historically carried the streetcar line and still runs directly through Old North Knoxville. Downtown is about two miles away, so the daily commute is straightforward for most people.
Fourth and Gill is bounded by I-40, Broadway, Central, and Hall of Fame Drive. That positioning gives you immediate interstate access if you're regularly heading to other parts of Knox County. Old North Knoxville sits just north of those boundaries, which adds a few minutes to highway access, but the same direct route down Broadway is right there.
Public transit runs through both areas via Knoxville Area Transit (KAT), with bus stops along Woodland Avenue, Central Street, and Broadway. If you don't want to drive downtown, you don't have to.
Parks, Dining, and Daily Amenities
Daily life in both districts revolves around independent commercial corridors and neighborhood pocket parks. The streetcar suburb layout means sidewalks are built in and mature trees line the blocks - walking to nearby businesses isn't an afterthought, it's just how the neighborhoods function. Where they differ is in which parks and which commercial strips are at your doorstep.
Green Spaces and Trails
Old North Knoxville has First Creek Park, an 18-acre space with a greenway for biking and jogging along the neighborhood's eastern edge. There's also Beth Ann Booker Park - a smaller pocket park with a playground, a gazebo, and a Little Free Library.
Fourth and Gill's primary outdoor space is Fourth & Gill Park, which has trails, a picnic area, and a playground. Both districts give you enough green space for daily walks without getting in the car.
Commercial Districts and Dining
Fourth and Gill's commercial activity centers along Broadway. Bryant's Market was historically a focal point for the neighborhood; today, "The Birdhouse" - a former church turned community center - serves as the main hub for neighborhood events.
Old North Knoxville's commercial life runs along Central Avenue and the adjacent Happy Holler Historic District. That corridor has antique shops, bakeries, bars, and the Three Rivers Market food co-op. North Central Street specifically has local staples like the Original Freezo ice cream counter alongside a growing mix of coffee shops, vintage stores, and breweries.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference in home prices between Old North and Fourth and Gill in Knoxville?
Fourth and Gill generally commands higher prices. Recent data shows median sale prices there ranging from $520,000 to $595,000. Old North Knoxville homes typically sell between $385,000 and $429,000, which gives you a more accessible entry point into the historic district market.
What types of homes are available in Old North vs Fourth and Gill?
Both neighborhoods have homes built between 1880 and 1940. Fourth and Gill is widely recognized for its Queen Anne and Victorian "painted ladies," along with Gothic and Mediterranean Revival styles. Old North Knoxville has a similar mix of Late Victorian and Queen Anne properties, with a large concentration of Bungalow and Craftsman designs.
Are there stricter historic zoning rules for renovating homes in Fourth and Gill compared to Old North Knoxville?
No - both operate under H-1 overlay historic zoning, so exterior renovations in either district follow the same specific local preservation guidelines. Hundreds of homes across both neighborhoods have gone through successful restorations under these rules since the 1980s.
Which neighborhood offers better walkability and commute times to downtown Knoxville, Old North or Fourth and Gill?
It depends on your exact address, but both offer direct access to downtown, which sits about two miles away. Fourth and Gill is bounded by I-40 and Hall of Fame Drive, so interstate access is slightly faster from there. Old North Knoxville is just to the north, but both use the Broadway corridor and KAT bus routes for the downtown commute.
Is Old North Knoxville or Fourth and Gill better for buyers wanting to live close to local breweries and coffee shops?
It depends on which commercial area you want outside your door. Old North Knoxville is adjacent to the Happy Holler Historic District on Central Avenue, with breweries, coffee shops, and the Three Rivers Market food co-op. Fourth and Gill centers its commercial activity along Broadway and sits just to the south, keeping it close to the same amenities.
How quickly do houses typically sell in the Fourth and Gill real estate market versus Old North Knoxville?
Across the broader Knoxville market, the recent median was 54 days on the market. In historic districts like Old North and Fourth and Gill, sales volume is low - which means well-maintained properties often move faster than the citywide numbers suggest. Knoxville homes generally sell for about 97.5% of list price, so plan to compete if you find something worth writing an offer on.
How do these historic districts compare to suburban areas like Farragut?
Old North Knoxville and Fourth and Gill offer historic streetcar suburb layouts with high walkability to local commercial corridors. Buyers looking for a different pace or a more traditional suburban layout might prefer the Farragut area instead.
Are there other historic neighborhoods near downtown Knoxville to consider?
While Old North Knoxville and Fourth and Gill are popular choices along the Broadway corridor, buyers often look at other nearby historic districts. Areas like the Fort Sanders neighborhood also offer older homes and a straightforward daily commute to downtown.
Check out this article next
